As India prepares for the opening ODI against England in Nagpur to be played on February 6, the selection of the primary wicketkeeper-batter has garnered significant attention. The squad for this series includes both KL Rahul and Rishabh Pant, offering the team flexibility in their lineup, but who is going to be in the playing XI is the big question. If Rahul is a reliable option in the middle-order, Pant is a match-winner. The wicket-keeper selection conundrum is actually quite a tough nut to crack.
Why?
Rahul has been India’s preferred wicketkeeper in recent ODIs, especially during Pant’s absence due to injury. His consistent performances with the bat and reliable wicketkeeping have solidified his position. He is someone who is been there done that type. Whereas, Pant, having recovered from his injury, has been included in the squad for the Champions Trophy but is still looking for that consistency tag in white ball cricket. His aggressive batting style and left-handedness provide a contrasting option to Rahul. 
Given the upcoming Champions Trophy, the team management might use the ODI series against England to assess both players’ form and fitness. This approach would help in determining the optimal combination for the tournament. The final decision on the first-choice wicketkeeper for the series and the Champions Trophy will likely depend on various factors, including current form, fitness levels, and team balance considerations.
Which means. Rahul’s consistent performances have positioned him ahead of Pant in the selection race. As for Yashasvi Jaiswal, despite his impressive form, securing a spot in the playing XI is challenging due to the presence of established players like captain Rohit Sharma and his opening partner Shubman Gill.
With head coach Gautam Gambhir demonstrating a willingness to make bold choices, he may opt for Rahul ahead of Pant. Rohit may have a different take, who knows? The main challenge will to balance form and experience. The top batting line-up otherwise looks simple — Rohit and Gill doing the job of opening in the innings with Virat Kohli at one down followed by Shreyas Iyer at No. 4, who is going to be No. 5 and 6? Surely, Hardik Pandya will be in there along with a wicket-keeper batter followed by other spin all-rounder options.
Sources have also indicated that only a miracle could see Pant in the playing XI while there are some voices who even saying that leaving out Pant would be a huge mistake because of his good numbers against England in ODI. Won’t Pant play then or would he play in place of Iyer? India had multiple wicket-keeper batters in the playing XI in the past, why can’t it happen again?